When Alex Legend brings home Bonnie Rotten from their date, he's surprised to find a second version of his girlfriend waiting: Bonnie's identical sis, Bunny Smitten! Although Bunny seems like the good girl version of her bad girl sister, Alex is about to learn that appearances can be deceiving. As Alex eats Bonnie's pussy, Bunny sneaks up under the table and sucks his cock while her sis is none the wiser. Alex has to choose which tattooed blonde to fuck, and he picks the pussy he's never had before. But Bunny's got some surprises in store, because this innocent-seeming beauty likes it rough, and she wants Alex to fuck all her holes and cum in her mouth!